Truffle care

How to Tell If Magic Truffles Have Gone Bad

Magic truffles are fresh, living produce, so yes, they can go off. The good news: spoiled truffles are easy to spot once you know what to look for. Here’s the simple check we use in our shop, with real photos.

Last updated: November 2026 · Photos by Pascale

Unopened, in the fridge2–3 months Sealed vacuum pack at around 4°C.
Opened, in the fridgeUp to 1 month In a container lined with paper towel.
Gone bad whenMushy or smelly Slimy, sour or rotten, or coloured mould.
01

Can magic truffles go bad?

Yes. Magic truffles (sclerotia) are the underground part of a living fungus. After harvest they keep breathing, and like any fresh produce they slowly break down, faster when they’re warm, wet or exposed to air.

How long they last depends on how you store them:

How they’re storedStays freshNotes
Sealed pack, in the fridge2–3 monthsAround 4°C, in the dark
Opened, in the fridgeUp to 1 monthContainer lined with paper towel
At room temperatureA few daysFine during delivery, then fridge
Fully dried, airtight jarUp to 1 yearCool, dark and completely dry
02

4 signs your magic truffles have gone bad

  1. Texture: soft, mushy or slimy. Fresh truffles are firm and slightly springy. Spoiled ones give way when you press them, or feel wet and slippery.
  2. Smell: sour, rotten or ammonia. Fresh truffles smell mild, earthy and a little nutty. A strong, sharp or rotten smell means they’ve gone off.
  3. Colour: very dark, black or wet-looking. Spoiled truffles turn dark and shrivelled, often with dark, wet or gooey patches.
  4. Mould: green, black, grey or pink spots. Any coloured, powdery or dusty growth is mould.
Spoiled
Fresh
Spoiled dark magic truffles next to fresh, light-coloured magic truffles
Left: spoiled, dark and shrivelled. Right: fresh, firm and light. 

Spoiled: throw them away

Fingers pressing a spoiled magic truffle that is soft and mushy
Soft or mushy truffles have gone off. 

Gives way when pressed. Wet, slimy or gooey. Sour or rotten smell.

Fresh and fine to use

Fingers pressing a fresh magic truffle to show it is firm
Fresh truffles feel firm when you squeeze them. 

Firm and springy. Dry surface. Mild, earthy smell.

03

Looks odd, but is completely normal

Not everything that looks strange means your truffles have gone bad. These are all normal:

  • Blue or dark-blue spots: natural bruising from handling. Not mould.
  • White, velvety fuzz: that’s mycelium, part of the living truffle. Read how to tell mycelium from mould.
  • A puffed-up vacuum pack: the truffles release CO₂ as they breathe. Open the pack and check them.
  • Slightly darker and drier with age: fine, as long as they’re still firm and smell normal.
Normal, tight seal
Puffed up with CO₂
Two vacuum packs of magic truffles: one sealed tight and flat, one puffed up with CO₂
A puffed-up pack is usually just CO₂ from the living truffles. Open it, check the truffles and move them to a lined container. 
04

The 1-minute freshness check

Take the truffles out of the pack, put them in a bowl in good light, and go through these steps:

  1. Check the date: look at the use-by date on the label.
  2. Look: light brown to beige, plump, with no wet patches or coloured spots.
  3. Smell: mild and earthy is good. Sour, rotten or ammonia is not.
  4. Squeeze: press one gently. Firm and springy means fresh. Soft or mushy means spoiled.
05

What to do next

They passed the check

  • Use them, or put them straight back in the fridge
  • Once opened, move them to a container lined with paper towel
  • Use opened truffles within about a month

They failed the check

  • Throw the spoiled truffles away
  • Don’t cut off bad parts and don’t try to dry them to “save” them
  • Check the rest of the pack

If in doubt, throw it out. Spoiled truffles can upset your stomach and make for an unpleasant experience. If you’re not sure, send us a photo and we’ll help you check.

06

How to keep magic truffles fresh for longer

  1. Fridge straight away at around 4°C, as soon as your order arrives.
  2. Keep the pack sealed until you use them.
  3. Once opened, use a clean container lined with paper towel, and add a silica gel packet to keep moisture down.
  4. Don’t freeze fresh truffles. Ice crystals damage them and they turn mushy when thawed.
  5. Want to keep them longer? Dry them fully and store them in an airtight jar.
Opened magic truffles stored in a container lined with paper towel
Opened truffles in a container lined with paper towel, ready for the fridge. 

Every method, step by step: How to Store Magic Truffles and Mushrooms.

07

Frequently asked questions

Can I use magic truffles after the use-by date?

The date is a guide for quality. If they’ve been in the fridge, are still firm and smell normal, they’re usually fine shortly after it. If they fail any part of the 1-minute check, throw them away.

Do old truffles lose strength?

Slowly, yes, especially with heat, light, air and moisture. Cold, dark and sealed storage keeps them in the best condition for longest.

I left my truffles out of the fridge. Are they ruined?

A few days at room temperature, for example during delivery, is fine. Put them in the fridge and do the 1-minute check before you use them.

Are dark truffles always bad?

No. Truffles get a bit darker with age and dried truffles are much darker than fresh ones. Dark plus soft, wet or smelly means spoiled.

Can dried truffles go bad?

Fully dried truffles last up to a year in an airtight jar. If moisture gets in, they can go mouldy. Any fuzz, soft spots or a musty smell means throw them away.

Can I freeze truffles so they don’t go bad?

We don’t recommend freezing fresh truffles. The fridge, or drying for long-term storage, works much better.

Fresh truffles, packed in Utrecht

Every order is vacuum-sealed, kept cold and shipped fresh from our shop. Not sure about your truffles? Send us a photo and we’ll help.

Join the weekly journal

Storage tips, new research and members-only deals, once a week. Save 5% on your first order.